What the leadership style test shows
Every leader has habits. One prefers to give clear instructions, another asks the team first, a third lets people get on with it. These habits make up your leadership style. The leadership style test shows which style you lean towards when you don’t stop to think – in other words, in everyday work.
The test uses 14 typical leadership situations: a new team member, a project going off the rails, a crisis, a demotivated team, an employee proposing a completely different approach. Each situation offers five reactions that stand for five leadership styles. At the end you see which style you chose most often, which comes second and how your answers are spread.
You can take the test even if you don’t yet have a formal leadership role. Just think of situations where you led a project, a group or a volunteer team. Leadership doesn’t start with a job title but with taking responsibility for others – on a large or a small scale.
The five leadership styles at a glance
Our model distinguishes five styles. None is good or bad in itself – each suits certain situations and teams better than others:
- Directive: sets clear goals, methods and deadlines and stays in control. Strong in a crisis and with inexperienced teams.
- Coaching: develops individuals, asks questions instead of giving answers and makes time for conversations.
- Participative: involves the team in decisions, seeks consensus and draws on everyone’s knowledge.
- Delegating: hands over responsibility, trusts people to work independently and stays in the background.
- Visionary: points to an inspiring direction, explains the why and leaves freedom on the how.
Lewin, Goleman and situational leadership
Research on leadership styles has a long history. In the late 1930s, Kurt Lewin and colleagues studied how groups behave under autocratic, democratic and laissez-faire leadership. These three styles still shape many textbooks today. Our directive style resembles the autocratic one and our participative style the democratic one – except that we don’t see them as better or worse.
In 2000, Daniel Goleman described six leadership styles in the Harvard Business Review, including coaching, democratic and pacesetting styles as well as one that wins people over to a shared vision. His central point: effective leaders master several styles and switch between them depending on the situation. A similar idea underlies Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard’s situational leadership model, in which the right style depends on how developed the team member is – ranging from directing to delegating.
Our test is our own simplified take on these ideas. It doesn’t reproduce any of the questionnaires mentioned, but picks up the core message all these models share: there is no single right leadership style.
Why good leadership is flexible
Picture three situations. A new team member is on their second day – they need orientation and clear steps, so a directive style fits. An experienced team is planning a project it knows better than you do – here participative or delegating works. And after a restructuring, everyone is asking what it’s all for – now the visionary style is needed.
It becomes a problem when one style turns into the only answer. Leaders who are always directive hold experienced people back. Those who always delegate leave newcomers on their own. Those who always involve everyone lose valuable time in a crisis. And those who only paint visions lose credibility when implementation stalls.
So a useful question is: which style comes naturally to me, and which one is missing? The style with the lowest score in your spread is often the one you can practise most.
The pace of an organisation plays a part too. In calm phases there is time for participation and coaching; under heavy pressure many leaders automatically fall back on instructions. That’s understandable, but it can mean a team goes quiet exactly when its ideas are needed most. If you know your style under stress, you can consciously counteract it.
How to use your result
You learn most when you compare your self-image with how others see you. A few suggestions:
- For your main style, note one situation where it worked well and one where it did harm.
- Ask two or three team members for feedback: “How do you experience my leadership when things get tight?”
- Pick a low-scoring style for the coming month and use it deliberately in a suitable situation.
- Discuss in your leadership team which styles are represented – a team full of directive leaders feels different from one full of coaches.
- Retake the test after six months and compare.
Limits of the test
The test shows how you assess yourself. In leadership especially, self-image and how others see you often diverge: some leaders, for example, think they are more participative than their team experiences them. So take your result as a starting point for conversations, not as a verdict.
Leadership also depends on environment, industry and company culture. A hospital emergency department needs something different from an advertising agency. And: the test is not a tool for assessing leaders and must not be used for HR decisions.
When answering, notice whether you’re thinking of your current team or a previous one. Leadership develops with experience, and in a new environment your result may shift considerably. If in doubt, take the test separately for different teams.
Experiencing leadership when roles are reshuffled
Things get interesting when leaders tackle a task where experience and hierarchy count for nothing. On a Secret Mission in Vienna, a leadership team suddenly faces clues, actors and decisions at real locations – and sometimes someone other than the most senior person takes the lead. Afterwards it’s easy to talk about which style would have helped in the moment and who showed it.