Which detective are you? There’s an investigator in all of us
Which detective are you when something suddenly goes missing, someone contradicts themselves or a story doesn’t add up? Almost everyone investigates all the time, just without a badge: we draw conclusions from small clues, read faces, look things up and ask questions. This quiz turns that into a game and shows which of six investigator types you are closest to.
The questions describe small investigative situations: a theft, a witness who contradicts themselves, a case that has stalled. There are also questions about your favourite crime stories and how you behave at a murder mystery dinner. Your answers add up to a profile. Most people have a clear main type and a second strength – and that mix is what makes your own investigation style.
The six investigator types
The types are original characters, not copies of famous detectives. Each stands for a method of solving cases – in novels and in real life.
- The Logician: relies on pure reasoning, tests every assumption and reaches the solution by elimination.
- The People Reader: reads faces and undertones and always asks about the motive first.
- The Forensic Expert: trusts fingerprints, fibres and facts and builds a watertight chain of evidence.
- The Bloodhound: is out and about, knocks on doors, asks questions and keeps at it until someone talks.
- The Archivist: researches, compares old files and finds the answer where it was written down long ago.
- The Chief Inspector: leads the team, hands out tasks and pieces everyone’s findings together.
Great role models from crime fiction
Crime fiction has made each of these styles famous. Edgar Allan Poe’s 1841 story The Murders in the Rue Morgue, featuring the sharp-witted C. Auguste Dupin, is often considered the first modern detective story. Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes became the epitome of the logician who draws far-reaching conclusions from tiny observations. Agatha Christie created two opposites: Hercule Poirot trusts order, method and his “little grey cells”, while Miss Marple relies on a knowledge of human nature that she transfers from village life to every case.
The American hardboiled novels of Dashiell Hammett and Raymond Chandler put the bloodhound on the streets with Sam Spade and Philip Marlowe – investigators who have to ask their way through a tough city and take a few knocks. Georges Simenon’s Inspector Maigret solves his cases with patience, empathy and a well-oiled team. R. Austin Freeman’s Dr Thorndyke is seen as an early example of the scientific detective, long before forensic TV series became popular. And modern novels feature researchers who strike gold in archives and databases.
How real investigation works
In reality, hardly anyone solves a case alone. Detectives, crime scene investigators, forensic pathologists and prosecutors work together, and each brings its own method. Investigators carefully distinguish between circumstantial evidence – a clue that points to something – and proof that establishes a fact. Many pieces of circumstantial evidence together can paint a strong picture, but each one has to be checked.
Much of the work is patient routine: interviewing witnesses, comparing statements, securing and documenting evidence, reading files. That is precisely why the types in this quiz complement each other so well. The forensic expert makes sure nothing gets lost, the people reader notices when someone is evasive, the archivist finds links to earlier cases and the chief inspector holds it all together. Fictional detectives may be lone geniuses – in real life the team usually wins.
Fair play: why good mysteries invite you to play along
A good puzzle mystery, often called a whodunit, lets the reader investigate too. Every clue needed for the solution is in the text – you just have to interpret it correctly. During the golden age of the classic detective novel between the world wars, the British writer Ronald Knox even set out tongue-in-cheek rules for fair mysteries in 1929, such as that the culprit must appear early in the story and that no unknown poisons or supernatural powers may be involved.
The same principle applies to mystery games. At a good murder mystery dinner, puzzle evening or live mission, the clues are spread so every investigator type can contribute: physical evidence for the forensic expert, conversations for the people reader, documents for the archivist and contradictions for the logician. If you know your type, you know what to look out for – and which clues to leave to the others.
How to use your result at your next mystery night
Whether it’s a murder mystery dinner at home, an escape game or a puzzle evening: an investigation team is strongest when different types come together. Compare your results beforehand and assign roles deliberately.
And if everyone has the same type? That isn’t a problem, it’s a clue. A group made up entirely of Logicians should make a point of taking conversations with characters seriously; a table full of People Readers would do well to write down facts and times. In that case, ask a few people to play their second strength on purpose. It is often the most entertaining part of the evening, because you see yourself from a new angle – and can laugh at your own blind spots at the end.
- Logicians keep the list of alibis and test every claim.
- People Readers handle the conversations with suspects.
- Forensic Experts examine objects, photos and props.
- Bloodhounds chase every open question until it is answered.
- Archivists remember names, dates and backstories.
- Chief Inspectors gather everything and lead the final reveal.
Investigate for real: mystery experiences in Vienna
If you want to test your investigator type beyond the screen, you can investigate for real with Secret Mission in Vienna. Your group takes on a case and solves it with professional actors at real locations around the city – no locked room, but witnesses waiting to be questioned, clues that need checking and decisions that shape the outcome. Missions are played in English or German.